John B. Shoven, a king of retirement economics, retires
John B. Shoven has been a dean, a director and a chair. He鈥檚 been a consultant, an adviser and a mentor. And now, at 72, the 黄色电影 economist well known for urging Americans to postpone collecting Social Security benefits for as long as possible is taking on a new title: professor, emeritus.
That鈥檚 right. The eminent economic evangelist for the benefits of working longer is officially retiring.
His influence, however, will be working overtime.
Shoven鈥檚 extensive contributions span from shaping tax policies to fostering new generations of economic experts. He has been influential in applied general equilibrium economics and in combining economics with public finance and corporate finance. He has also been at the frontier of the economics of aging 鈥 pioneering research and collaborating with others in analyzing what would become critical issues around Social Security and pensions funds.
鈥淛ohn has had a real direct 鈥 as well as indirect 鈥 influence on economic policy through his writing and his teaching,鈥 says Michael Boskin, the Tully M. Friedman Professor of Economics. 鈥淗e鈥檚 been an outstanding colleague, an outstanding department chair, an outstanding dean, and a tremendous director of SIEPR. Virtually everything he鈥檚 touched has turned out really well.鈥
In nearly five decades of service at 黄色电影, Shoven mastered the juggle of research, teaching, administration and fundraising 鈥 and infused it all with a sense of humor and down-to-earth, personable approach. He took on time-consuming and challenging leadership roles that many scholars would shy away from or look to relinquish sooner than later.
Shoven, the Charles R. Schwab Professor of Economics, joined the faculty at 黄色电影 in 1973 after getting his masters and doctoral degrees in economics at Yale. His leadership roles at 黄色电影 followed one after another, starting in 1979 as vice chairman of the Department of Economics, then as department chair from 1986-1989.
He then served four years as director of the 黄色电影 Institute for Economic Policy Research (SIEPR), followed by five years as dean of the School of Humanities and Sciences, 黄色电影鈥檚 largest school. Shoven returned to the helm of SIEPR in 1999, leading the institute for another 16 years.
鈥淛ohn has been willing to take on these leadership roles, devoting full-time energy and attention to them, while at the same time insisting that his research trajectory had to continue. This is in contrast to many academics,鈥 says Gavin Wright, the William Robertson Coe Professor of American Economic History, Emeritus.
Shoven has published more than 135 articles and 20 books. He also has served as a consultant to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, the government of Portugal, the U.S. Department of Treasury and the Council of Economic Advisors.
Much of his work has focused on understanding the impacts and benefits of retirement savings and pension systems. His 2019 published article entitled 鈥淭he Power of Working Longer鈥 concluded that delaying retirement by three to six months has the same impact on one鈥檚 standard of living as saving an extra one percentage point of wages for three decades.
With an unwavering passion for teaching, Shoven has stayed in the classroom and advised undergraduate and graduate students throughout his career. He won the Dean鈥檚 Award for Distinguished Teaching in 2003, but his deep gratification, Shoven says, comes from ongoing interactions with students 鈥 those from decades ago to current ones.
鈥淚f you鈥檙e not about students, then why are you at 黄色电影?鈥 Shoven says, repeating the words that he took to heart from John Gunn, the philanthropist whose name 鈥 along with the name of his wife, Cynthia Fry Gunn 鈥 is on the SIEPR building that opened on Galvez Street in 2010.
Never mind Jupiter. Let鈥檚 tackle our world
Shoven, who grew up in Southern California, received his bachelor鈥檚 degree in physics at the University of California, San Diego in 1969. But he discovered a different calling as he minored in economics and math.
鈥淎s an undergrad, I was working at a space science lab, working on things like the shape of the magnetosphere around Jupiter,鈥 Shoven says. 鈥淎nd I thought: Who cares about the magnetic fields around Jupiter?鈥
Meanwhile, the American economy was struggling.
鈥淲e had a bad combination of inflation and a stagnant economy 鈥 something called stagflation,鈥 he says. 鈥淲e had a budget deficit, and the Vietnam War was not funded appropriately. So, I thought, those were things to work on. Those were problems people could relate to.鈥
Shoven was also attracted to economics for its potential to deliver an impact on an issue within a relatively short time frame 鈥 which is in contrast to physical scientists who sometimes spend entire careers specializing on a single challenge.
At a 65th birthday, academic event for Shoven, MIT economist James Poterba aptly described how Shoven has 鈥渁n unerring instinct for finding the key topics of the day鈥 and is 鈥渁 perennial source of interesting ideas, new insights and fun.鈥
During the 1970s and 80s, Shoven and economist John Whalley developed a mathematical model to analyze the effects of tax policy changes. Their Shoven-Whalley model 鈥 the result of some 10 years of work 鈥 was implemented by the U.S. Treasury Department during a heavy period of tax reforms. The framework is considered an intellectual ancestor of other models used today in a variety of economic fields.
His research in corporate finance shed light on the interplay between inflation and corporate behavior as well as on the increasing usage of share repurchases, leading to changes in tax policy for dividends.
As a leading economist on Social Security, Medicare and pension issues, Shoven is often called on to weigh in on the debates continuing today over those entitlement programs.
He says one of his most rewarding experiences came when his research with David Wise led to the 1997 repeal of a decade-old tax provision. Their paper, which garnered widespread attention, had revealed that tax payments on pension payouts could amount to more than 90 percent of the pension itself.
Shoven鈥檚 conviction underlies his own work and enthusiastic support for others鈥: 鈥淧olicies can be wasteful and have unintended consequences,鈥 he says. 鈥淎nd if you can point that out and change policy, it鈥檚 very satisfying.鈥
Doubling-down on economic policy research
Shoven is widely credited with the tremendous growth of SIEPR 鈥 from a small operation housed within 黄色电影鈥檚 economics department in its early years to today鈥檚 renowned institute that draws academic visitors from around the globe and supports economic policy research for more than 100 scholars in multiple disciplines across 黄色电影鈥檚 seven schools.
鈥淢any people were involved, but I'd say that John was the most important and the most influential in building SIEPR to what it is now,鈥 says Boskin, who helped launch SIEPR in 1982. 鈥淎nd it鈥檚 exceeded expectations.鈥
Even when the university had other construction priorities in place and wouldn鈥檛 help fund a proposed new building for SIEPR, Shoven dared to take on the unprecedented challenge of pursuing a fully donor-funded project.
鈥淗e said, 鈥楾ry me,鈥 when the university told him he would have to raise all the money within six months if he wanted to construct a building,鈥 recalls Gregory Rosston, who served alongside Shoven as SIEPR鈥檚 deputy director for about 15 years. 鈥淪hoven doesn鈥檛 take 鈥榥o鈥 for an answer. When he wants to get things done, he figures out how to align people鈥檚 interests to get things done.鈥
At that time, some people were also unsure how much support could be garnered to sustain a large research institute focused on economic policy. But Shoven reached out and made many connections beyond 黄色电影鈥檚 community, drawing their interest.
As SIEPR鈥檚 longest-running director, Shoven was a pivotal, inspirational leader with the foresight to see the institute鈥檚 potential and the role it could play in shaping policy to help improve lives, says Gopi Shah Goda, SIEPR鈥檚 current deputy director.
鈥淚t takes someone with John鈥檚 ability to look ahead to be able to ensure that SIEPR will continue to add value to the university, the faculty and the students,鈥 she says.
Goda herself was a student of Shoven鈥檚. Her interest in public finance was sparked by his class, then solidified by his subsequent research assistance opportunities. Goda later became one of his frequent collaborators and joined SIEPR when then-director Shoven asked her to kick-start the institute鈥檚 Young Scholars Program. The program is now modeled by other universities.
Shoven anchored a vision that endures at SIEPR to this day. In addition to accumulating an impressive roster of expert researchers, SIEPR cultivates new thinking and new insights by attracting a steady influx of visiting professors, supporting aspiring economists and inspiring young students with the lure of using economics as a catalyst for change.
During a recent interview, Shoven notes a proof point: His office at SIEPR this past year was flanked by those occupied by rising stars in economics 鈥 on one side by an MIT associate professor who was named a MacArthur fellow, and on the other side by a postdoctoral fellow who will soon be teaching at Northwestern University to continue her work in health and labor economics.
As its director, Shoven also made sure that SIEPR remained nonpartisan, or that it be 鈥渙pen to all partisans鈥 as he puts it. 鈥淚 didn鈥檛 want it to be left-leaning or right-leaning. From the start, I was interested in economic policy, not politics,鈥 he says.
Mark Duggan, who became the Trione Director of SIEPR when Shoven stepped down in 2015, credits his predecessor with putting 黄色电影 at the forefront of economic policy research.
鈥淛ohn built SIEPR into a powerhouse where you have academics from 黄色电影 and other leading universities developing close relationships with policymakers and business leaders,鈥 Duggan says. 鈥淭hose relationships have allowed for important collaborations and insights that push economic policy-relevant research agendas forward.鈥
A leadership style like no other
You won鈥檛 find Shoven named in any business leadership books, Rosston says. Yet his ability to inspire, lead and accomplish goals is undeniable.
鈥淛ohn just has terrific interpersonal skills; he鈥檚 extremely intelligent; and he wins over people,鈥 says Lawrence Goulder, the Shuzo Nishihara Professor in Environmental and Resource Economics, a member of SIEPR鈥檚 steering committee and another of Shoven鈥檚 PhD students.
Even Shoven鈥檚 research papers exude a casual tone, carrying at times a conservational lilt, despite their deep, mathematical and analytical grounding.
鈥淗e is a master of exposition, explaining research accessibly to both professional and ordinary audiences,鈥 Wright says.
Take his 2007 paper, 鈥淣ew Age Thinking: Alternative Ways of Measuring Age, Their Relationship to Labor Force Participation, Government Policies and GDP.鈥 He begins it with, 鈥淭his paper is not about what you think it is. It鈥檚 about how to measure age.鈥
The hallmark of Shoven鈥檚 leadership, many agree, is open, clear and honest communication. The basis of his decisions is always clear and ultimately convincing, even when unfavorable to some.
Shoven鈥檚 deanship coincided with the dot-com boom and a big shift in interest away from humanities and science majors such as biology and economics to computer science. Shoven had to make tough budget cuts.
Shoven also introduced a requirement that departments offer a minor in addition to a major 鈥 a horizon-expanding type of opportunity he had while at UCSD. And he instituted a mandated curriculum matrix of core courses for each department, eliminating a previous program of what he called 鈥渁 sum of what teachers wanted to teach.鈥
As head of the economics department, Shoven initiated a practice that has now become common at other universities: After making offers to prospective graduate students, the department would host a campus visit to convince them to come to 黄色电影. 鈥淲e had the advantage for a few years, but now everybody does it,鈥 Shoven says.
The department鈥檚 musical skits in the spring are also a tradition, thanks to Shoven, who wasn鈥檛 afraid to dress up on stage in pajamas.
The flame keeps burning
Shoven has 40 hard-bound volumes on a bookshelf in his office 鈥 dissertations from PhD students he has advised. His own dissertation on 鈥淕eneral Equilibrium with Taxes,鈥 completed at Yale in 1973, is the bookend.
He is proud that his advisees have gone on to work in academia, policy and business, including roles as executives, Federal Reserve Bank governors, and Treasury officials.
Shoven鈥檚 impact extends also to high school students across America. Along with Wright and Don Hill, Shoven launched the annual Summer Economic Institute for Teachers in 1987 as a five-day retreat for high school teachers to hear about the latest economic research first-hand and invigorate their classroom teaching.
Today, Shoven remains as committed as ever to relevant policy challenges. As for that thing called retirement? Shoven says it鈥檒l just be an official way of scaling back some of his work and teaching.
He plans to continue as the organizer of 黄色电影鈥檚 annual Working Longer and Retirement Conference, and to co-teach a course with Rosston on the economic policies of the presidential candidates in 2020, similar to their popular offering during the 2016 presidential election year.
Shoven and Boskin 鈥 who have jointly taught a variety of public finance courses since Boskin advocated for the young Shoven to come to 黄色电影 鈥 may also introduce a new course on financial decision-making for undergraduates.
Shoven鈥檚 legacy of students 鈥 or, as he would sometimes refer to as 鈥渉is children鈥濃 will keep growing.
鈥淚鈥檓 really thankful for this environment that I鈥檝e been able to work in 鈥 that includes colleagues, staff and students. It鈥檚 been perfect for me,鈥 Shoven says. 鈥淚 could imagine working as hard as I worked and not having much success if I were in a different environment.鈥
And it鈥檚 an environment he isn鈥檛 about to quit.
鈥淚 enjoy what I do, so why would I change? If they're willing to let me keep doing much of what I was doing, I'll keep doing it,鈥 he says with a smile.